Humble servant of the Nation

TV news isn’t fake but too often it isn’t news

SHARE
, / 12616 456

There it was yesterday. A plethora of Australian journos standing mic in hand in front of the Champs Élysées or the Eiffel Tower reporting on the French presidential election.

The trouble was what they were doing was not reporting. Or to be more precise, they started with a little reporting and then moved quickly on to speculation and opinion.

Welcome to Australian media’s version of the Kon Tiki tour. With elections looming in the UK and the French National Assembly in June and elections in Germany in September, it’s all aboard the bus. When you get there, don’t worry so much about factual reporting. Tell us what you reckon.

On last night’s ABC News at 7.00pm, the ABC’s European correspondent, Lisa Millar, spent the first five seconds repeating the result and then moved full steam into divination. To be honest, it wasn’t her fault. She faced questions posed from the desk in Sydney from newsreader, Juanita Phillips, all of it demanding a “What do you reckon?” response.

Ms Millar spent the bulk of her report waxing on what might happen by Christmas and beyond.

Full column here.

 

456 Comments

  • The Bow-Legged Swantoon says:

    If you’ve got the time this is interesting:

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TB0k7wBzXPY

  • Rhys Needham says:

    Watching Seven afternoon ‘news’ briefly yesterday and it appears to me that it’s essentially turned into a less toxic version of Today Tonight. Little news, just a crappy ‘consumer affairs’ show.

    • Razor says:

      I used to be an electronic news junkie but over the last 12mths or so I’ve come not to bother. Like you say current affair rubbish dressed up as news. The 1 hour bulletins were the beginning of the end. They need to fill that time with something.

    • Wissendorf says:

      TDT? Bill Peach? Is he at 7 now? I thought he died. Maybe working for 7 is a kind of death. (Just checked – died a few years back.)

    • Trivalve says:

      Tolja

  • Huger Unson says:

    David Brooks (NYT) laments.
    The Russian leak story reveals one other thing, the dangerousness of a hollow man.
    Our institutions depend on people who have enough engraved character traits to fulfill their assigned duties. But there is perpetually less to Trump than it appears. When we analyze a president’s utterances we tend to assume that there is some substantive process behind the words, that it’s part of some strategic intent.
    But Trump’s statements don’t necessarily come from anywhere, lead anywhere or have a permanent reality beyond his wish to be liked at any given instant.
    We’ve got this perverse situation in which the vast analytic powers of the entire world are being spent trying to understand a guy whose thoughts are often just six fireflies beeping randomly in a jar.

    • Henry Blofeld says:

      Hilarious bleat there dear Huger old buddy from David but as James Morrow writes the rabid Left is playing Donalds song and it will all benefit Trump. The Democrats are smarting badly still after losing the unlosable election because of a hopeless candidate in Hilary Clinton. It will all settle down when Trump continues on for many years to come. Two terms is my prediction and James Morrows too in the linked article. Poor Mr Baptiste on this blog has already eaten the packet his Wheaties came in due to frustration, bless his cotton socks, him being a great supporter of Kimmie of North Korea. Cheers.
      http://tinyurl.com/lvvqrvo

      • Jean Baptiste says:

        Kimmie says “Pah” capitalist running dog false hair fat bastard pig eyes President is not long before finish. Not so good stop mighty North Korean rocket this time hey?”
        No particular reason for this post Nossy, other than for the $5.00 per word I’m getting now. In cash, US dollars from my bestie Kimmie, and my impeccable politeness in always replying to you of course.
        I look forward to your posts. Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha.
        (See what I did there? By spacing the ha’s I get an extra forty bucks.)
        Kind wishes.

  • Henry Blofeld says:

    “Have Tool, Will Travel”, Mr Insider, and of course I refer to dear Mr Pyne and Turnbulls exciting news today re the massive Shipbuilding work “soon” to commence in SA. Goodness, only a small number of foreign workers going to be required, says Mr Pyne. They may be the chaps fitting the Nuclear Reactors into the bowels of the Barracuda Submarines? Gosh and strewth Aussies can do that, just follow the instructions on the box they come in!

  • BASSMAN says:

    an incredible interview on the latest george pell accusations….john faine
    pell was smart….he rigged so that unlike other countries the catholic church cannot be sued here…sorry…no capitals…nursing new daughter

    http://www.abc.net.au/radio/melbourne/programs/theconversationhour/the-conversation-hour/8508980

    • BASSMAN says:

      It is about this:- George Pell’s cunning brilliance is personified by The Ellis Case. Briefly The Ellis Case is a famous court case that set up a precedent that concluded you could not sue a Catholic Diocese. Ellis sued the church in Sydney for compensation as a result of his sexual abuse by a priest and claimed damages. The church responded by saying the Trustees of the Catholic church cannot be sued because they do not employ priests-who does then?.The church claimed it was not a legal entity and therefore could not be sued because it was not responsible personally for any abuse that allegedly occurred by any individual priest. The church spent $50million on this one case to set up a successful precedent that obviated the church of any responsibility. This is unique to Australia. Elsewhere in the world, especially the USA, victims received sometimes million dollar payouts. But not in Australia thanks to George Pell. No matter how bad the abuse is I think the limit is $50k.

    • Razor says:

      Congrats on the new arrival Bassy! I hope she lives long and prospers! Mum also well I hope.

  • Tracy says:

    Ian Brady finally dead, will take a long time for the stain he and Myra Hindley left on the north of England to fade.

  • JackSprat says:

    What is going on?
    People lie about their refugee status, return to their own country that they fled because their lives were in danger for a holiday, their visa gets revoked and the Administrative appeals Tribunal overturns the revocation of the visa.
    http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/immigration/refugees-feared-for-lives-but-returned-to-iran-for-holidays/news-story/a57da4238e97d78da11545c6804ea436
    About time the bureaucrats of Canberra get a dose of reality.
    Maybe shift them all out to a country towns where they will rub shoulders with people who have their feet squarely on the ground.
    Maybe just get rid of the whole lot and start again.
    There used to be an old adage – always have a head office in front of a factory because otherwise they forget what they are there for and build empires.
    Canberra is living in a bubble that they have created for themselves and are feeding off one another – ably lead by the Fishwyck Pravda.

    • Razor says:

      I was gobsmacked when I read about it JS.

    • Trivalve says:

      Who are the members of this trinunal?

      • Carl on the Coast says:

        The LNP plonked the RRT into the AAT in 2015. They should have junked it, especially as the refugee issue was a large successful conservative policy plank that led to the Abbott government gaining office. The Immigration Minister should hold the delegation and final say on all citizenship-related issues in his/her office. Perhaps that’s where it may be heading after this latest fiasco.

      • Dwight says:

        Any guess as to who appointed the current head? http://www.fedcourt.gov.au/digital-law-library/judges-speeches/justice-kerr/Kerr-J-20120516.rtf

        But, I believe his term expired today.

      • BASSMAN says:

        Probably the same bastards who Roboted me!

      • The Bow-Legged Swantoon says:

        I think the AAT works as separate units in each State. It’s been a long time now since I was in the visa cancellations business (although I did once know a lot about it at both the policy and practical level). It’s my understanding that the Migration Review Tribunal and the Refugee Review Tribunal were rolled into the AAT by Abbott and Morrison on the basis that they had become captive by the industry.

        As previously discussed with Jack in Honkers review processes (whether through the courts or tribunals) tend to favour giving people – especially people who arrived with no documents, and stories that could be neither verified or refuted – the benefit of the doubt. It’s an in-built bias in the system. The lawyers and activists know this and so do their clients.

  • Uncle Quentin says:

    Any idea the point Clement is trying to make in today’s OZ, because I’m buggered if I can get it.

  • Jean Baptiste says:

    I’ve been meaning to put a link to this story.
    Onya girl Onya bloke.

    http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-02-28/mark-colvins-kidney-donation-becomes-theatre/8312356

    • Henry Blofeld says:

      Heartwarming, Mr Baptiste, just amazing how this good deed by Ms Ellen-Field came to be a play. Thanks for posting indeed. I did not see the play sadly. Cheers.

    • G Wizz says:

      ABC are showing a retrospective of Colvin’s career tomorrow night. A must view item.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

PASSWORD RESET

LOG IN