Humble servant of the Nation

Students’ climate change strike is a walk in the park

SHARE
, / 3554 121

Picture: Mark Metcalfe

The wolves are at the door. The barbarians are at the gate. In the streets of our major cities, the Visigoths and Vandals come in the form of spotty-faced, badly dressed humans, bearing backpacks, bottled water and moral certainty.  

By mid-afternoon, capitalism could be a tyre fire and by the morning, our new overlord could be a 15-year-old girl who likes hip-hop, chatting with friends on FaceTime and global conquest.    

In response to the national and global rallies, Australian commentators invoked Stalin, Lenin and Mao. Boil them all up in your Pol Pot and we’re good to go.

More particularly, the arguments went, the spotty-faced ones should be sent to their rooms and be given no Marxist dialectics for supper.

Then it is only a matter of time before we are dragged out of our cars while waiting at the drive through of fast food restaurants, and torn limb from limb. The newspaper boy could be planning to burn our houses to the ground.

It has all got a bit silly.  

My question is, when did we become opposed to freedoms of assembly, association, movement and expression?

Hundreds of thousands of the nation’s kids will enjoy these freedoms today and express their fears and frustrations at the uncertainty of their future and that of the planet we all live on.   

You don’t have to like it, you don’t even have to understand it, but you should respect it.

Frankly, I don’t think our federal parliamentarians have got a dog in this fight or if they do it is a toothless cavoodle who remains stubbornly asleep on the couch.

When asked about hashtag climatestrike, Bill Shorten had five bob each way, as Bill is prone to do.

“Kids are allowed to have opinions,” he said yesterday. But there was a caveat. There always is with Bill. “In an ideal world, they would protest after school hours and on weekends.”

He went on to say the government had been “On strike about climate policy for the last five-and-a-half years.”

“(Scott Morrison and his government) are really not the best role models for the kids on climate policy, are they?”

I would have thought a former union boss would understand the basic principles of a strike but there you go. His comments were more than an each-way bet. Bill took two fields in the quinella with a complicated boxed trifecta thrown in for good measure.

I’d love to be his bookie.

On the other side of the divide, Liberal senator, Concetta Fierravanti-Wells decided to blame Tony Abbott’s opponent in Warringah, Zali Steggall.

“Why,” the Senator tweeted, “is Zali Steggal encouraging kids to wag school to go to a climate rally? Kids shouldn’t be brainwashed but if they really want to protest, let it be on their own time.”

The federal parliament has sat for a neat seven days in 2019. By the May election, it will be nine days. Over the same period, school students around the country have been in the classroom for 90.

Seven sitting days to date. If our federal parliamentarians took a leaf out of the students’ book and went on strike, how would we know the difference?

Seriously, if the Canberra mob decided to pull the pin, how would we even tell?

According to Finance Minister, Matthias Cormann, wages in Australia should be linked to productivity. By my back of the envelope calculations, the productivity of federal MPs is down a whopping 800 per cent on previous year and that’s not based on an excruciating time and motion analysis but merely on the days they bother to turn up. Yet, at the end of each month the Commonwealth pays your bog ordinary MP a base salary of almost $17,000 and that doesn’t include perks, a car and too may expense allowances to list here.

I could also mention that in the dark days of the August spill last year the doors to the House of Representatives were locked shut because the government feared it would lose its majority on the floor and be hurled off the Treasury benches.

Truth be told, it was more lock out than a strike. But the fact remains, when it comes to our MPs, it is a case of the old teacher’s axiom, do as I say, not as I do.

By the time you read this article, hundreds of thousands of children will have gathered in the nation’s capitals and regional cities. There is bound to be a bit of bad language, amusing and sometimes rude placards and a bit of good-natured hoppo-bumpo with the rozzers.  

We shouldn’t be too bothered about this either. It is the job of youth to mock authority. Indeed, if they didn’t do it, I’d be worried. I would fear the generation, sometimes called the i-Generation but more properly referred to as millennials, were nothing more than a race of sullen automatons staring at their phones. That they are to a degree politically active and informed is cause for celebration not condemnation.  

A month ago, we had actual Nazis congregating on St Kilda Beach. At the time, I heard no apocalyptic predictions from the commentariat. Indeed, the general view then was that these people, appalling as they are, were entitled to congregate, meander about menacingly and generally be as awful as they possibly can be.

And that view is the correct one. Again, you don’t have to like it, but you should respect it.  

By comparison with that ugly little episode, the climate rallies held today will be a walk in the park.

Take a packed lunch, kids. Drink plenty of water. Pack a jumper. Don’t catch a chill. Enjoy your freedoms. Have your say. Oh, and apply sun block. The sun’s a killer these days.

This column was first published in The Australian on 15 March, 2019.

121 Comments

  • JackSprat says:

    Just voted.
    I noticed the ALP was preferencing the Greens second.
    Daley said that there would be no coalition with the Greens when he got decimated by Gladys last night in the debate.
    The guy handing out the ALP how to vote cards was good value and we had a bit of a good natured chat – he did suggest that I read Marx.
    With supporters like that, small wonder why they are preferencing the Greens in NSW who are, in the main, a bunch of ex-communists.

  • Dismayed says:

    The latest rubbish report morriscum and the coalition have latched onto has already been debunked and proven to be rubbish. “SQM Research’s managing director, Louis Christopher, was a big supporter of negative gearing reform Then in 2016, Christopher flip-flopped, releasing an incredibly superficial report that was comprehensively debunked by Dr Gavin R Putland. “As we all know, Labor’s policy will redirect negative gearing tax benefits into newly constructed dwellings, which would make new dwellings relatively more attractive to would-be investors, thereby helping to increase construction and lower rents (other things equal).” “Overall, this is very superficial analysis that has attempted to re-write history, alongside misreading the likely impact on construction and rents.”
    https://tinyurl.com/y44yezrd

  • wraith says:

    Scomo wasnt impressed. Me either. so how about those trade sanctions? And as for travelling to Turkey for the Gallipolli nonsense, grow up people and honour your dead at home. The need for you to parade around the world laying wreaths so everyone can see how cool, deep and wonderful you are, is outweighed by the risk to life and the political storm it will cause.
    Console yourselves by doing what all the other insecure losers do, get a tattoo.

    • Jack The Insider says:

      Turkish imports run at about twice the value of what we export to them so a sanction would hurt them but I think this will all calm down fairly quickly. Erdogan is a terrible piece of work and I think ScoMo and Bill have been right to call out his appalling language. Ardern sent Foreign Minister Winston Peters over to Ankara for a ‘please explain’ in person. I imagine Erdogan will keep him waiting in the lobby, leaving his sidekicks to try and smooth things over. As some friends of mine used to say in a few pubs I used to drink at, “If you want to mouth off, sooner or later you’re going to have to look someone in the eye and get your dooks up.”

    • Jean Baptiste says:

      Sanctions? Pussy stuff. I reckon they fluked us last time. Lets give ’em a real surprise next Anzac Day.

    • Perentie says:

      That’s a bit rough, Wraith. I haven’t been there for Anzac Day, but Gallipoli is well worth a visit. As are many parts of Turkey for that matter. Interesting culture, great people.

      Don’t take any notice of Erdogan. He’s just a weak leader mouthing off in a futile attempt to sound like a strong one. Sound familiar? There’s something of a glut of those around the world at the moment.

  • Henry Donald J Blofeld says:

    The NSW State Election this coming Saturday, Mr. Insider, the 1st of the “Big Two”, the other being the Federal Election, still to be called.
    As an outsider looking in and reading how NSW’s Economy is the best in Australia surely Premier Gladys Berejiklian and her Team would deserve to be voted back in for another term?
    Here linked is ABC Election Analyst Anthony Greens take on the NSW State Election for “Mexicans” like myself.
    http://tinyurl.com/y64x9jqh

    • Jack The Insider says:

      Thank you. I voted yesterday pre-poll and according to the NSWEC, a lot of people now do. Daley has had a shocker over the last couple of days and Gladys has some questions to answer today about the footy stadium in Paddo. The question is how much of this matters with so many people pre-polling? I’m not sure how it will pan out on Saturday night. Labor minority government with the support of the Greens who will pick up another one or two and hold another in the northern rivers’ seats. Nats to get thumped in the bush, so there maybe some wins to the Shooters etc Party. Those are my guesses.

      • jack says:

        I can’t pretend to put my finger on it, but I just don’t like the growth in Pre-polling.

        something about it doesn’t seem quite right.

        • Jack The Insider says:

          In NSW, we can pre poll ten days out. Not sure about the feds but it might be a bit longer. It certainly reduces the influence of a campaign. In my neck of the woods, I’ve seen queues out the door and down the street at the local prepoll booth. I ducked in, not to vote but to ask a few questions of the NSWEC workers and they think they’re on track to get a half of the electorate voting before election day. Tough on the sausage sandwich makers.

  • Milton says:

    Another fine article by John Silvester in The Age today. He cuts to the core of things and makes a lot of sense. He must be reading my mind!!!

  • Milton says:

    As Elvis sang ” A little less congestation a little more action”. Vote Abbott for Warringah. He da manly man for tunnels and static toilets.

  • Milton says:

    It’s obviously plain to see that all those who hate Pauline Hanson are bigoted, sexist totalitarians. And big government are colluding with the media to shut down social media because they have no control over the thoughts and commerce that it enables and in which Big Brother is scrambling to control. It is seemingly ok for the US, Russia and China to impose their force, or business, or neglect human rights, and for Hollywood and the rest of the world’s film industry to churn out graphic violent movies, ditto the computer gaming, and for the media to live stream the wars in Baghdad and the former Yugoslavia, as well as other horrors and tragedies nightly, but not ok for people to access equally violent shit on social media; nor for individuals to express their opinions or beliefs, no matter how much we disagree with them. They hide further and further into the caves of the internet. For God’s sake i had a hard time dealing with the images from mainstream media of people about to beheaded. And the 9/11 footage I watched live, and it is constantly repeated. Both the politicians and media have proven themselves to be hypocrites and believe only they are in a position to decide what is good for us. And I would add that political correctness hasn’t helped and it too seems more than a lot hypocritical. And that dictate has a strong hold in our education systems.
    And after the horror we get a lot of he said/she said, a total non-entity and marginal character like Anning dominating the headlines, an attention seeking kid with an egg being hailed a hero (must be the Ned Kelly worship in some of us – but at least Kelly knew how to ward off an egging) , and a whole lot of people who fail to realise, or choose to ignore, that the far right and the far left are at/in the same place but in different garb but with equally mad and controlling manifesto’s. Jesus wept, the mass murdering terrorist has written that he was at one time a communist, anarchist (!), libertine and now an eco-terrorist. Essentially a self-aggrandising killer looking for a cause or flag to shoot under. An egotistical loser, who like Martin Bryant, happened to receive a lot of money at an early age that freed them enough to pursue their sick agenda.
    Apologies for length (always wanted to say that!)

  • Jean Baptiste says:

    Thats bollocks. The EEC was formed for scale of economy and ease of trade barriers to compete with the USA and the Soviet Union both with vast resources.
    While the states comprising the EU haven’t been to war with one another , a real bonus, it’s not the reason it was formed. The EU has dramatically lifted the wealth of Western Europe , but as predictable as night following day in capitalism the wealth is ever more siphoned off by the wealthiest.
    Much as the mil/industrial complex is appalled, wars between major powers are long redundant. Theres still a quick buck to made in the grand old tradition of beating up small resource rich nations and plundering the said resources. There are still a few plums to be picked.
    Lets see how the Poms go after Brexit. They need a reality check.

  • wraith says:

    You see this is nice. Never miss a chance to sink the boot in. That is why this woman will always be ‘them’ and never a part of any us anywhere really. Is there a country she might feel at home? We wouldnt want to hold her up.
    https://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/hypocrisy-zealand-claim-190319104526942.html

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

PASSWORD RESET

LOG IN