Humble servant of the Nation

TV news isn’t fake but too often it isn’t news

SHARE
, / 12627 456

There it was yesterday. A plethora of Australian journos standing mic in hand in front of the Champs Élysées or the Eiffel Tower reporting on the French presidential election.

The trouble was what they were doing was not reporting. Or to be more precise, they started with a little reporting and then moved quickly on to speculation and opinion.

Welcome to Australian media’s version of the Kon Tiki tour. With elections looming in the UK and the French National Assembly in June and elections in Germany in September, it’s all aboard the bus. When you get there, don’t worry so much about factual reporting. Tell us what you reckon.

On last night’s ABC News at 7.00pm, the ABC’s European correspondent, Lisa Millar, spent the first five seconds repeating the result and then moved full steam into divination. To be honest, it wasn’t her fault. She faced questions posed from the desk in Sydney from newsreader, Juanita Phillips, all of it demanding a “What do you reckon?” response.

Ms Millar spent the bulk of her report waxing on what might happen by Christmas and beyond.

Full column here.

 

456 Comments

  • jack says:

    Mark Colvin, i looked at his twitter feed just the other day, had a photo of his dog visiting him in hospital.

    just reading the responses he was much loved by his colleagues and peers, another great loss.

    • Jack The Insider says:

      He was a terrific bloke, mate. You would have enjoyed his company. Smart, funny and wise without a smidgeon of conceit. He had an anecdote at the ready on most occasions but didn’t contrive the opportunity to tell them. When he did it was pure joy. His story on scooping the commercial networks on the death of ‘Aussie Bob’ Trimbole in Spain was a ripper. Generous, big-hearted, brave and bright. We lost a good one today.

  • Rhys Needham says:

    Vale Mark Colvin. A huge loss to Australian journalism and far more.

  • Henry Blofeld says:

    PM Turnbull in Parliament, Mr Insider, like the Dentists Drill, high pitched and goes on and on. If the average Aussie voter ever warms to this cove I will eat my socks!

  • Huger Unson says:

    Ah yes, Jack, journalists! A collective pain in the scrotum. Always sticking their beaks into politicians’ business. Why can’t they butt out and let our *elected* officials get on with it. The fewer the better, I say. If we must have them, why can’t they be subject to scrutiny & licensing by the government of the day?
    Lock up a couple, just for the hell of it, then they’ll come to heel.

  • G Wizz says:

    Vale Colvinius . Mark Colvin, long time presenter of ABC’s PM has passed away from a rare disease he acquired on the job. Great presenter gone too soon. RIP Mark.

    • Jack The Insider says:

      Indeed, GW. He was a fine man. I was lucky enough to have got to know him well the last five or so years. He was a big-hearted, wise, smart, funny and thoroughly decent human being. I visited him in hospital a week or so ago and while his long term prognosis was not good, the news of his death came as a complete shock. We should celebrate his life and his contribution to this country. His last tweet was a posthumous one, presumably typed in by a family member. “It’s all been bloody marvellous.” Thank you, Mark. It has been our honour and you have been bloody marvellous.

  • Trivalve says:

    And in a most unhelpful turn of events, given the topic, Colvinius has left the building. Great shame. Vale Mark.

    And also my surviving aunt overnight. Two in two weeks, from a total of two.

    • jack says:

      TV, sorry to hear of your losses, it does get to the time of life when one seems to get weekly reminders of mortality.

      i used to chuckle when i arrived home after the paper round to find Dad, with his e and b plate pushed back and enjoying his morning cuppa and toast and scanning through the death notices in the Melbourne Sun, and eager to tell me where this or that one fitted in to the very large numbers of families we knew.

      that sort of scanning seemed an odd thing to do then, but not now.

    • The Bow-Legged Swantoon says:

      Commiserations, TV. That’s a big chunk of family to lose in such a short time.

  • Uncle Quentin says:

    I heard Hillsong this morning being asked by Fran Kelly about why he wasn’t keeping the higher income levy. He furnurled out something about . Funny how taxes on the wealthy are class warfare and the politics of envy whereas taxes on the rest of us are sensible budgetary measures…

    • Uncle Quentin says:

      Correct version
      I heard Hillsong this morning being asked by Fran Kelly about why he wasn’t keeping the higher income levy. He furnurled out something about . Funny how taxes on the wealthy are class warfare and the politics of envy whereas taxes on the rest of us are sensible budgetary measures…

      • Lou oTOD says:

        Have you started drinking early again UQ?

        The “correct version” is identical to the presumably incorrect version above it. I can only take it you are conceding both are incorrect.

        I recommend double strength, extra hot coffee before Midday, that should keep you lucid.

  • G Wizz says:

    Tips in but the only real upsets I can see this week are Saints/Blues where I think Carlton have enough to poke Saints in the eye, and Suns to surprise Port. I didn’t like tipping the Hawks but the Lions are not a team to back just now and they’ll freeze down in Tassie. If a draw was an option in the tipping I’d tip this one for a draw.

    • Lou oTOD says:

      The Suns won the battle to wear their home strip of red and gold G, which of course are China’s national colours. Kotchie was really pissed off (Port home game and they didn’t twig).

      Now I can’t imagine the trouble Port will have leaving the country if they do the Suns over, so you could well be in the money.

      As for Carlton poking the Saints in the eye, I’m telling you you’re dreaming. Oh by the way, good old Carlton have done it again, finding a million dollar black hole in the club’s finances. When will they ever learn?

      • Jack The Insider says:

        A million bucks. Pfft. Smoke night at the Pratts will sort that right out. The Saints are two years ahead of the Blues in development. Bigger bodied. I’d expect them to win, especially at Etihad.

      • G Wizz says:

        The Shanghai stadium holds 10,000 and it’s a sellout. That will be 10,000 voices cheering the Gold and Yellow. I think the Blues have found something judging their last 2 outings. They’ve been more accurate inside the 50 and are finding ways to get there. It will probably be the game of the round.

  • Henry Blofeld says:

    J. Edgar Hoover, Mr Insider, this is the type of chap POTUS Trump needs at the FBI, here in this short clip giving his thoughts on the dreadful spread of Communism. Well said indeed, lets keep the “Pinkos” at bay!
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YtcjMYYbLdc

    • Jean Baptiste says:

      A criminal and a traitor Nossy. In cahoots with Washington elites ignoring widespread corruption at high levels, in cahoots with powerful criminal organisations and a vicious manipulative bully ,racist and bigot.
      He played the confected communist threat card for all it was worth. A paranoid tyrannical enforcer for the interests of Americas most influential private citizens. A very nasty piece of work.
      No doubt a hero archetype holding great appeal for the shadow Nossy lurking under the froth and bubble persona.

      Love your work Enery.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

PASSWORD RESET

LOG IN